More info for the terms:
density,
forest,
fuel,
litter,
prescribed fireBlackjack oak associated with eastern redcedar is more likely to be
top-killed by fire because eastern redcedar is highly flammable and
fires tend to be hot. A severe fire in a post oak-eastern redcedar
community in the Wichita Mountains of Oklahoma top-killed 92 percent of
all trees (post oak, blackjack oak, and eastern redcedar) greater than 3
inches (7.6 cm) in d.b.h.; only 13.5 percent of the top-killed blackjack
oaks and post oaks sprouted. In the adjacent post oak-blackjack oak
forest, only 66 percent of trees greater than 3 inches (7.6 cm) were
top-killed by the fire, and 70 percent of these sprouted [
40].
There is disagreement in the literature as to whether blackjack oak is
more susceptible to fire in a savanna or in a forest. A March fire in a
central Oklahoma oak savanna top-killed most oaks smaller than 1.6
inches (4 cm) in d.b.h. and top-killed or severely damaged some trees up
to 3.5 inches (9 cm) in d.b.h. In the adjacent post oak-blackjack oak
forest, however, few woody stems larger than 1 inch (2.5 cm) in d.b.h.
were top-killed. In the savanna, all litter was consumed, whereas only
45 percent of the litter in the adjacent forest burned. The authors
suggest that lack of grass under a closed-canopy forest results in a
much cooler fire [
23].
However, an investigation of the effects of a prescribed fire in March
in a savanna and adjacent blackjack oak-black hickory forest in central
Illinois showed the opposite effect: savanna blackjack oaks were less
affected by fire than blackjack oaks in the adjacent closed-canopy
forest. Patterns of fuel consumption around isolated mature blackjack
oaks in the savanna showed that fire never reached the base of the
trees. A few trees had slightly scorched lower branches, but all trees
survived the fire. In the closed-canopy forest, mortality of trees
[stems larger than 3.5 inches (9 cm) in d.b.h.] was high. Three years
after the fire, the density of blackjack oak had decreased from a
prefire density of 179 trees per acre (443 trees/ha) to 74 trees per
acre (183 trees/ha). In essence, the fire converted the closed-canopy
forest to an open-canopy forest. Seventy-five percent of top-killed
trees had basal sprouts 1 year after the fire [
2].
The difference in fire effects on blackjack oak in the Illinois savanna
and forest was attributed to the difference in fuel load. Estimated
average fuel load was 2.5 ounces per square foot (840 g/m sq) in the
savanna and 8.0 ounces per square foot (2,671 g/m sq) in the forest. In
the savanna, fuel load was further reduced under mature blackjack oaks
because grass growth was less in the shade created by the down-sweeping
branches, and the wind removed excess leaf litter. In the closed-canopy
forest, understory fuels built up over time [
3].
The results of these two studies indicate that the effect of fire on
blackjack oak is dependent on surface fuel load.